Gracie loves all things treats, but shes particular about them. I tend to lean towards the healthiest stuff because she need to be healthy in order to live forever. I was given Sweet Pups Cookies to have Gracie try. Normally, she will sniff them, then hide them and never touch it. When I gave her a Sweet Pups Cookie, she devoured it so fast I couldnt even get a picture of her eating it. Needless to say she was so happy when I gave her another one. The packaging is on point. Will never not buy Sweet Pups as its only for the best. TREAT YO SELF. TREAT YO DOG.